How to Prepare to be the Perfect Panelist
How often have you accepted an invitation to join a panel, only to wonder afterwards what on earth you were thinking?
There you are, sitting on stage, trying to look intelligent and engaged while the moderator fires questions at you that are either completely outside your area of expertise or so far out of left field that you briefly wonder whether you’ve wandered into the wrong conference.
You try to deflect, improvise and generally look as though you know what you’re talking about. Meanwhile, the audience is wondering why you were invited in the first place, and you’re wishing you’d asked a few more questions before blithely accepting the invitation.
That conference in Geneva, with the tempting prospect of some pre-Christmas skiing, suddenly doesn’t seem quite such a good idea!
This is not a far-fetched scenario. I’ve witnessed it at conferences and heard similar stories from people I coach to become better panelists.
Based on my experience as a professional moderator and coach, here are my top tips for preparing to be a great panelist.
- Interrogate the organiser (politely, of course!)
It’s flattering to be invited to speak on a panel. It can also be tempting to say yes immediately, particularly if it’s a prestigious event, an interesting location or an excuse to add another trip to your travel calendar.
But before you accept, stop and do a little due diligence. Here are the questions you should be asking:
- What is the objective of the panel? What are the organisers hoping to achieve?
- Who is the audience? What do they already know? What do they want to learn?
- What do they expect you to bring to the discussion? Why have they invited you specifically?
- How many panelists will there be? More than four is a red flag. Unless the session is unusually long, you’ll be fighting for airtime.
- How diverse is the panel? Consider gender, race and age, as well as professional backgrounds and perspectives. Do you really want to be part of a manel (an all-male panel)? Apart from the fact that it makes for a rather narrow discussion, it can attract some fairly unwelcome attention on social media.
- What is the format? If you want to be part of a dynamic discussion, look for a moderator-led question-and-answer format. Be wary of panels where everyone is expected to deliver a three-to-five-minute opening statement. Welcome to death by panel!
- Where do you overlap with the other panelists, and where do you differ?
- How long is the session? Around 45 minutes is ideal. An hour can work with a good moderator and a strong format. An hour and a half? That’s a very long time to keep an audience engaged.
- Ask for a concept note. Yes, really!
A concept note is essentially the briefing document for the panelists and moderator. It should provide a clear picture of what the session is about, how it will work and what everyone is expected to contribute.
Ideally, it should include:
- A catchy title and a clear rationale: Why this topic? Why now?
- An introduction to the panelists: What does each person bring in terms of expertise, experience and perspective? How do they relate to one another?
- Three key themes: Think of these as chapter headings that will structure the different rounds of discussion.
- Questions for all panelists: These should give everyone an opportunity to contribute.
- Specific questions for individual speakers: These should play to each person’s expertise and encourage them to bring something distinctive to the discussion.
- A final forward-looking question: Something that leaves the audience thinking about what comes next, rather than simply summarising what they’ve just heard.
As a moderator, I always ask for a concept note. Sadly, I rarely receive one that ticks all these boxes!
- Insist on a briefing call with the moderator
This is absolutely vital – both for you and for the moderator.
In my experience, the occasional panel where I haven’t been able to speak to the panelists beforehand has invariably been suboptimal. And when the panel doesn’t work, the audience suffers too.
A briefing call is your opportunity to get everyone on the same page before the event. It offers several advantages:
You can discuss the questions.
It’s a chance to challenge, amend and suggest questions. Perhaps one is too broad, another is repetitive, or there’s an important issue that has been overlooked.
You can get a feel for the moderator.
How knowledgeable are they about the subject? Do they understand the issues, or will you need to provide some background? This is also the moment to flag topics you aren’t qualified to address or simply don’t want to discuss.
Of course, you’ll still need to be prepared for audience questions – but more on that in my next blog!
You can understand their moderating style.
Will they stick rigidly to their prepared questions, or are they comfortable going off-piste? Do they ask follow-up questions? Will they invite you to comment on what another panelist has said? Are they hoping for an exchange of views between particular panelists?
You can establish how much airtime you’ll get.
With several panelists competing for attention, it’s worth understanding how the moderator intends to manage the discussion. Will everyone get equal opportunities to contribute, or will certain speakers take the lead on particular themes?
You can make an honourable exit!
Yes, this does happen. The briefing call may reveal that the panel isn’t quite what you expected, that the subject matter is outside your expertise, or that your contribution would be rather marginal.
This is your opportunity to say, diplomatically, that you may not be the right person for the discussion – and perhaps suggest a more suitable colleague from your organisation or sector.
Better to do this before the event than discover it halfway through the first question!
In my experience, this situation often arises because the panelist hasn’t asked enough questions of the organiser or hasn’t received a proper concept note.
In my next blog, I’ll share tips on how to deliver a top performance on the day !